Granular vs. Liquid Fertilizer: Which Should You Use?

well kept lawn using granular and liquid fertilizer

When it comes to fertilizers, there are two main types: granular and liquid. Each type has its own set of pros and cons, which is why it can be tough to decide which one to use. Join the Elite team as we examine the benefits and drawbacks of each so that you can make an informed decision about which type of fertilizer is right for your lawn!

What's The Difference?

Nutrients found in grass clippings all around new grass leaves

Before going any further, let’s be clear on what we mean by the terms “granular” and “liquid” as they pertain to lawn fertilization. The NPK ratio denotes the levels of nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium, respectively, that are present in the fertilizer. Though both granular and liquid fertilizers contain these same macronutrients, the different form and delivery system of each are what create the unique benefits.

 

  • Granular fertilizers are composed of solid particles that are usually applied with a spreader or directly by hand. These granules dissolve slowly in the soil and release their nutrients over time. Granular fertilizers do not need to be reapplied as often because of their slow distribution, but they will need to be watered into your lawn to take effect.

 

  • Liquid fertilizers are made of dissolved minerals that are sprayed onto the lawn with a hose-end sprayer or a tank sprayer. They provide quick absorption because they do not need to be dissolved in the soil first. Liquid fertilizers are easy to apply, and they are the best choice for more immediate results in your lawn.

Pros & Cons Of Granular Fertilizer

hands holding granular fertilizer for a lawn

Granular fertilizer is the more popular choice between the two options in the United States. In fact, research indicates that as much as 90% of homeowners and lawn care enthusiasts use granular fertilizer over liquid. This is not necessarily to say that granular is always the better choice, but it clearly provides some benefits to users.


  • KEY TAKEAWAY – Granular fertilizers are better for sustaining the long-term health of your lawn, but each granule has a unique nutritional makeup, which may result in an uneven lawn.

 

Pros:

  • Slow-release delivery system
  • Cheaper in bulk
  • Easy to store
  • Longer shelf life
  • Fewer applications
  • Easy to see and monitor on lawn

 

Cons:

  • Results take longer to see
  • Granules must be watered into your lawn
  • Varying nutritional content per granule
  • Can lead to uneven growth
  • Can lead to burning of turf in patches
  • Requires clean-up on paved surfaces

Pros & Cons Of Liquid Fertilizer

man applying liquid fertilizer to a freshly cut lawn

Liquid fertilizers are popular among users because of their ease of use and fast-acting results. From a professional standpoint, liquid fertilizers tend to provide better consistency in terms of coverage and nutrient distribution as well. Liquid fertilizers also have the benefit of not being displaced by things like the wind or foot traffic.

 

  • KEY TAKEAWAY – Liquid fertilizers are great for getting quick results, but they require frequent applications because of their fast-releasing nature.

 

Pros:

  • Quick results
  • Easy to apply
  • Covers more ground
  • Consistent nutritional content
  • No clean up required on paved surfaces 
  • Easier to tailor mixtures to specifications

 

Cons:

  • Costly compared to granular fertilizer
  • Frequent reapplications needed  
  • Shorter shelf-life
  • Turf stress caused by rapid growth
  • Can evaporate on hot day
  • Will wash away in the rain

Use Liquid Fertilizer For New & Dying Lawns

spraying fertilizer on a lawn

Whether you have a cool-season lawn or a warm-season lawn, tall fescue or Bermudagrass, both granular and liquid fertilizers can be effective when applied correctly! The only times liquid fertilizer is always preferable over granular is when a lawn is either just starting out from bare soil, or if a lawn is on the verge of dying.

 

Granular fertilizer has a higher salt content, which can be damaging to new seedlings trying to germinate. The inconsistent nutritional makeup of granular options also makes them not ideal for new lawns because you could easily end up with an uneven lawn right out of the gate! Lawns that are severely struggling and need a quick boost of nutrition also benefit from the quick-release delivery of liquid fertilizer.


  • What About The Bushes? For the bushes, shrubs, hedges, and other large plants in and around your lawn, use a slow-release granular fertilizer for perennials and a liquid fertilizer for annuals.

 

Use Granular Or Liquid Fertilizer In Spring & Fall

shrub and tree granular fertilization

Liquid fertilizers are beneficial year-round when they are applied correctly, and granular fertilizers have benefits during colder weather. Granules provide slow-release of nutrients over a long period of time, which makes them ideal for these seasons when growth is slower and more gradual. The higher salt content in granular fertilizers can also help to speed up the natural dormancy process of grass during the winter months. Liquid fertilizer is also effective in the cooler months, but be sure you are not applying too much as your grass enters dormancy. 


  • Granular Fertilizer Gets Down! When leaves and debris start falling onto your lawn at the end of the season, granular fertilizers will be able to reach the soil because they won’t be absorbed by the plant matter on top of your grass.

 

In Conclusion

When applied correctly, both granular and liquid fertilizers are effective tools in maintaining healthy, thriving lawns all year round! Granular fertilizers provide slow-release nutrition that sustains your lawn over a longer period of time, while liquid fertilizers offer quick results with frequent applications. 

 

Though granular is the more traditional option, liquid fertilizers are getting used more and more. To make sure you use the right fertilizer for your lawn, call your local lawn care company today!

CONTINUE READING

Algonquin IL | Lawn Care & Landscaping

Elite Lawn Care offers a full range of lawn care and landscaping services in Algonquin IL, such as mowing, fertilization, weed control, and snow removal, using advanced technology for a vibrant and healthy lawn. Choose Elite for hassle-free maintenance and enjoy a lush, beautiful green space at your home.

Read More »

When should I do a fall clean-up in Chicago?

When do you do a fall clean up in Chicago? Check out our comprehensive guide for Chicago fall cleanups. Find out why taking care of your outdoor spaces is important and how Chicago’s fall weather can make it challenging. Get your outdoor spaces ready for the season with these essential cleanup tips.

Read More »
Premium Dark Mulch

Which is the Superior Choice: Rubber Mulch or Organic Mulch?

Selecting the right type of mulch for your garden can be a daunting task. With countless options available, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons to make an informed decision. Two of the most popular mulch choices are rubber and organic. While rubber is cheaper, organic is a more environmentally friendly option that provides numerous benefits for your plants. It’s derived from natural materials like bark, leaves, and straw, which decompose over time and enrich the soil. Additionally, organic mulch helps retain moisture, suppresses weeds, and regulates soil temperature. Overall, organic mulch is the smart choice for a healthy and thriving garden.

Read More »